Airtime Screentime Facetime: a Live-Publication 10-11-23

  • Aymeric Mansoux
  • Michael Murtaugh
  • Michelle Teran
  • Senka Milutinović
  • Sofia Boschat-Thorez
  • Affiliated research project
  • Going Hybrid!

  • The launch of the final iteration of live publication, Screentime Airtime Facetime, took place on the 10th of November, 2023. It celebrated the end of the two-year cycle through questioning hybrid experiments and strategies in the cultural sector. Screentime Airtime Facetime was – and is – a hybrid experiment: a live publication, where event turns to book and back again and is finally transcribed. The livestream was hosted at

    Over the past two years, the research project Going Hybrid dedicated itself to the future of hybridity in the cultural field. Questions included, in this order: “Where will hybrid events take us?”, “Which platforms allow best practices for hosting cultural events, without ‘Zoom fatigue’?”, and “How can hybrid publications and living archives develop, so they can share these experimentally broadcasted events with diverse audiences?” During 2021, tools were developed to research (the use of) existing platforms, gather expertise and subsequently share findings with the public through articles, presentations, a conference, and finally a publication, to be published at the end of 2023, in the form of event, web, and print.

    During a process of gathering and planning for the different sub-groups and outcomes, following the practice/research question took the lead: “In what ways can program providers in the cultural and creative industries connect new and existing audiences to a hybrid, high-quality cultural program in a sustainable and technologically independent manner?”

    To quote Carolina Pinto’s summation of the processes behind Going Hybrid: “With its twists and roadblocks, forks and intersections, the research explored much more than that hybridity that comes to mind, with meetings and QR codes and avatars. Yes, the physical and digital have mixed and merged in hybrid new realities, but we intend to elaborate on hybridity beyond that: across media and spaces, challenging conceptions of hierarchy, access, time, and voices, that often come with different cultural experiences. How does hybridity shift the reading, writing, and publishing process? How can an archive become alive? And how can an audience interact in hybrid events? It was by confronting the first initial questions with deeper ones that we found meaning in this collective endeavour.

    The chapters in the hybrid publication put in conversation, quite literally, the working groups that have explored different aspects of hybridity and its outcomes in cultural settings. But — in the spirit of hybridity — we intend to understand where each of these outputs touch, the thread that goes across them and links myriad research experiments into one network. Each conversation is a chapter. These chapters will feature two different groups joined by a common red thread, a shared concern, approach, and motivation. These threads also function as steps at answering the research question – not necessarily straightforward solutions for fully functional programming, but ways to consider while going towards hybrid roads. These, more than single solutions, are features, concepts, key aspects that we have found to be essential to inclusive, critical and sustainable hybrid culture – across livestreams, publications or archiving.”

    The publication: Chapters and title

    Each chapter gives closer insight into the “glitches, awkwardness, and interruptions” of hybrid practices.

    Chapter 1, titled “Sound and Temporality”, connects the Living Archives group with the Participatory Livecasting group. In both these clusters, the concepts of what it means to be present and hybrid across temporalities of past, present and future were key in developing their research and experiments. Chapter 2, “Thresholds of Access”, will reflect on what kind of mediation is necessitated by live events in order to provide both human and technological access. The groups joining us for this chapter will be the Participatory Livecasting group and the Hybrid Publications group. Chapter 3 addresses the topic of “Interaction and Activation”, and includes speakers of the Living Archives group and Impakt. Both have questioned how relations between online and offline audiences and materials are formed, maintained and given space to become meaningful. The final chaper, Chapter 4, entangles and involves the Hybrid Publications group and the Experimental Publishing masters of the Piet Zwart Instituut to discuss different “Forms of Hybridity” and what kind of axis, attitudes and approaches to hybridity overlap in their research.

    The title of this publication, Screentime Airtime Facetime, connects different eras and aspects of hybridity. The title refers to the practitioners’ relation to technology in the past, present and future. This may mean that the (almost) notorious term, screentime, gestures towards a tendency to become too intimate with our screens, a one-on-one interaction. Airtime gives a nod to older forms of hybrids events; the times of families gathering to listen to the radio or watch TV. Facetime emphasises the immediate connections we foster with one another through, for instance, the use of video calls. With the gradual succession of these terms, we wanted to think through the tie to technology, to collective bodies and to each other (with technology as a mediator). What can we learn from a history of different hybrid interactions and take with us as seeds for the future?